Romandie.com
 
Créer un blog | Noter ce blog | Signaler un abus
 
| Autre blog ? >>  

Mon séjour en Afrique du Sud (Cape Town)

HUGE RAID ON HILLBROW BUILDINGS.

About 650 police officers, soldiers and government officials took part in a Thursday morning raid on two Hillbrow buildings used as a springboard for crime in the area, Johannesburg police said.

Superintendent Chris Wilken said the police contingent included members of the SA Police Service, the SA National Defence Force and home affairs department officials.

One of the targeted buildings is on the corner of King George and Wolmarans streets and the second building, Cresthill, is located on the corner of Twist and Peterson streets.

"Our sources have told us these two buildings are a springboard for crime in the area," said Wilken.

He said the police were after anyone involved in illegal activities, including dealing in drugs, possession of illegal firearms and armed robbery.

The Department of Home Affairs was involved in case any illegal immigrants were picked up, although this was not the focus of the operation. Two SANDF helicopters were also deployed.

More information regarding the raid would be released during the day, Wilkens said.


SANDF Members Receive Management Certificates.

The Pretoria Technikon yesterday awarded management certificates to 100 students, all members of the South African National Defence Force (SANDF).

The certificates were a culmination of a two-year course on the Senior Management Development Programme started in 1999 after the technikon was awarded a tender to provide training to SANDF members who had no formal academic qualifications.

The programme focuses on managerial development and aims to offer the SANDF members an opportunity for intense academic growth.

Professor Reggie Ngcobo, the technikon's Vice Chancellor told the graduation ceremony yesterday that 'to plan for the future people ought to think differently and do things in more innovative ways - especially as far as education and training are concerned.'

'Vibrant partnerships, such as this one between the Technikon and the SA National Defence Force, play an important role in the effective transfer of technology and skills, since a culture of innovation and entrepreneurship cannot exist in isolation,' said Prof Ngcobo.

As the Military Academy at Saldanah only caters for the training needs of young officers under the age of 25, the technikon programme specifically aims to give those above the set age an opportunity to obtain a formal qualification and advance their careers.

The principles of recognition of prior learning are applied when officers apply for the programme in line with SAQA requirements. It is envisaged that the SMDP will, in the long run, develop into a fully-fledged degree programme ranging from junior degrees to post graduate.


Steynsburg Gunman Arrested After Three-Day Manhunt.

The Steynsburg gunman who went on a rampage killing two people and wounding two others on Sunday, was arrested early yesterday (subs: Wed) morning.

Karoo police spokesperson Captain Erris (subs: Erris) Claassen said the 27-year-man was arrested three kilometres outside Steynsburg by Inspector Alfred Bhambatha at 6.50am yesterday (subs: Wed) after Bhambatha responded to a tip-off from the community.

Inspector Bhambatha was on his own when he found the man walking back to town along the R390.

Claassen said the man offered no resistance to his arrest and handed over the R4 rifle he had used to kill farm workers Kleinbooi Vuma, 60, and Patrick Maboza, 38, before handing himself over.

The gunman, who Claassen said could not be named until he was formally charged, used an angle grinder to break into his employer, sheep farmer Wikus Bekker's gunsafe.

After stealing an R4 rifle and ammunition from the safe he took Bekker's Isuzu bakkie and drove to Bekker's neighbouring farm Teebus Waters where he shot and killed Vuma and Maboza.

The man also shot 36-year-old Daisy Wuma in the leg.

He returned to Bekker's house on the farm Klipheuwel where he met farmer Charles Viljoen who he shot at, wounding him in the shoulder.

The man fled on foot, wearing a set of Bekker's SANDF fatigues, when police Captain TW Bartleman arrived on the scene.

Police and the SANDF launched a manhunt which continued for three days before the man was arrested yesterday.

The man would appear in the Steynsburg magistrates court tomorrow (subs: Fri) where he would be charged with two counts of murder, two of attempted murder, housebreaking and theft and the illegal possession of a firearm.

Claasen said "other charges" such as vehicle theft might be added to the list.

He said police were still collecting evidence for court.


FREEDOM FRONT CONCERNED AT SANDF SICK LEAVE RECORD.

The Freedom Front on Tuesday expressed concern at the state of health within the SA National Defence Force as portrayed by its latest annual report.

Said FF defence spokesman Pieter Groenewald: "The fact that nearly half of the members of the Defence Force took sick leave in one year, indicates poor discipline, low morale and costs the taxpayer money."

According to the 2002/2003 report, 42,2 percent of SANDF personnel took sick leave at a cost of R45,643,854.

More than 52 percent of the department's Public Service Act personnel took sick leave at a cost of R9,058,459. This totals R54,702,313.

In the same annual report, the Auditor-General mentioned that pressure on the defence budget negatively influenced the operational readiness, the morale and the working conditions in the SANDF.

Said Groenewald: "This confirms the low morale.

"The decision of the government to scale down defence force operations inside the country, in favour of peace keeping operations outside the country, is already taking its toll.

"Unless government acts swiftly and revises its policy regarding peace keeping operations, the situation in the defence force will deteriorate further."

The annual report was released with little fanfare about three weeks ago, a move since criticised by the Democratic Alliance.

"Government has set itself laudable principles of good governance of state departments based on openness, transparency and accountability to the public," DA defence spokesman Hendrik Schmidt said in a statement on Tuesday.

He added that the SANDF, however, had apparently decided to follow the example of its apartheid predecessor and to exclude the media and lawmakers from as much information as possible.

"A glance at the poor content of the so-called GCIS (Government Communication and Information System) meeting last week in Parliament where the media was 'briefed' on the latest developments affecting the department, in actual fact a rehashing of a previous media briefing, clearly illustrates this point," Schmidt charged.

Members of the media have also complained to MPs that they were apparently deliberately excluded by the department from last month's signing of a deal to purchase four maritime helicopters - despite them being present at another event at the same venue immediately before.

News of the long-anticipated purchase reached the media through reports from Europe, in turn based on a media release by AgustaWestland, the manufacturer of the Super Lynx 300 maritime helicopter.

Schmidt said other unclassified departmental documents have also never been formally made available to the media - and therefore the public.

"It furthermore appears that the Human Resource 2010 Strategy which has been informally released, has apparently never been formally made available to the media, despite such document being available for the past two years. So too, has the annual report of the SANDF been released without any notification thereof to the media."

Schmidt said the reluctance could be a kneejerk reaction to media reports critical of the military.

"The approach taken by the Department of Defence to prevent a reasonable disclosure of the affairs and events taking place within the Department, smacks of an autocratic styled department, fearful of having the true facts fully ventilated in the public domain," Schmidt said.

"It appears that the SANDF might have something to hide if notice is taken of the current reports which have been discussed in the Portfolio Committee and Joint Standing Committee of Defence."

The comments come a week after Lekota told journalists at Parliament that the country's defence budget had to be "urgently reviewed to prevent South Africa's defence capabilities being completely denuded." He wanted an extra R2-billion for defence. The current budget is around R21-billion or 1.6 percent of gross domestic product.

Later in the week he had to deny allegations of a long-running conflict between him and SANDF chief General Siphiwe Nyanda.

The Mail & Guardian on Friday reported Lekota and Nyanda had recently clashed over a plan, drawn up by Secretary of Defence January Masilela to transfer a number of divisions from Nyanda's command to the defence secretariat. Lekota emphatically denied the report.


SAfrican army chief, defence minister reportedly clash over army restructuring.

A blazing row over the restructuring of the Department of Defence has erupted between the South African National Defence Force (SANDF) chief, Gen Siphiwe Nyanda, on the one side and minister of defence. Mosiuoa Lekota and his director general January Masilela, on the other.

The row stems from Lekota's endorsement of Masilela's proposal to strip Nyanda of some of his powers in favour of Masilela, who heads the civilian section of the defence department, also known as the Secretariat for Defence.

Masilela compiled a report outlining his proposals after he was requested to do so at a council of defence meeting in June. Lekota had provisionally approved Masilela's proposals at the meeting. The report was submitted to Lekota in July.

Lekota endorsed the proposals six days later - despite Nyanda's protestation that some of the proposals were "untenable and unlawful".

Nyanda said Lekota should seek President Thabo Mbeki's input before endorsing Masilela's proposals. Alternatively, he suggested that Lekota set up a joint Secretariat-SANDF project team to analyze fully the implications of proposals and devise implementation options.

The proposals included, among other things, a recommendation that Lekota transfer a number of key SANDF divisions from Nyanda's command to the secretariat. The divisions include human resource management, military logistic, command and management information, and military legal services.

Nyanda charges that Lekota's decision would hamper him in discharging many of his statutory responsibilities - and would diminish the SANDF's capacity to defend the country.


SANDF SERGEANT FACES CHARGES FOR FIREARM NEGLIGENCE IN PT.

A South African National Defence Force sergeant'S son took a service gun to a Pretoria creche, SABC TV news reported on Thursday.

The man now faces criminal charges.

Sonica Oosthuizen, who teaches at the creche said her son who attends the creche, was excited to see the weapon.

"He said: 'Mama, mama there is a baby gun'," Oosthuizen told TV reporters.

She said she rushed into the room and found her son holding a real gun and immediately took it away.

The firearm was later confiscated by South African National Defence Force officials.


Opposition decries Pretoria's military expenses

Growing obligations of the South African National Defence Force (SANDF) in peace and support operations around Africa have stretched beyond its budgetary capacity, according to the opposition African Christian Democratic Party.

The party said the military was on the verge of collapse for want of funding, stressing the government needs to urgently review its attitude towards defence expenditure.

It said the current defence budget of only 1.6 percent of GDP compares very poorly to an average of 1.8 to 2 percent for developing countries.

"A recent assessment by command structures of SANDF indicates that an additional 2 billion rand is needed to enable the SANDF to meet all its obligations. The SANDF has been extremely thrifty over the past few years and there is a danger that the country is losing its capabilities," said ACDP spokesman Adriaan Blaas.

"We are now seeing the symptoms of insufficient funding manifesting in the total breakdown of communication in SANDF, a lack of discipline with increased reports of assault on senior officers, disregard for orders and unprofessional conduct by senior personnel and the promotion of unqualified personnel," Blaas charged.

He said every country, including South Africa should take pride in a defence force that should be disciplined, motivated, confident and in a state of readiness for any eventuality.

"The executive must accept responsibility for the collapse of SANDF, because without reasonable and sufficient funding, a reliable professional defence force cannot be sustained. They are not fulfilling their commitment to the constitution in that they neglect to provide for an effective defence capacity for South Africa," he said.

Meanwhile the official opposition Democratic Alliance said SANDF must carry out a detailed strategic review of its current threats and needs and balance their decisions against domestic needs and requirements.

"South Africa can play a meaningful role in peace support operations in Africa but this has to be weighed up against domestic security needs," DA spokesman Roy Jankielsohn said.

"The cost of foreign deployments in 2003 is one billion rand and is expected to cost an additional 2.4 billion rand between 2004 and 2006," he noted.


Burundi politics: Rebels demand Mr Ndayizeye's resignation

At a time when all parties are expected to be co-operating in efforts to make the peace process work, fighting has instead intensified, with the capital, Bujumbura, coming under sustained, direct attack. Starting on July 6th Bujumbura was attacked from both the north and south for seven days in the worst assault on the capital during the civil war. The attacks were carried out by the Parti pour la liberation des peoples Hutu-Forces nationals pour la liberation (Palipehutu-FNL), currently led by Agathon Rwasa, which has been at war on and off with the Forces armees du Burundi (FAB, the Burundian armed forces) since the early 1970s. Palipehutu-FNL was well-equipped for this latest assault, apparently sourcing weapons through Kamina in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), which suggests despite the DRC government's denials that some level of assistance or complicity with Burundi's Hutu rebel movements continues. All but one road into Bujumbura was closed for sustained periods during the week-long attack, making it hard for the FAB to bring in reinforcements from other areas. The capital does not appear to have been under serious threat of being captured by the rebels, but the FAB was caught unprepared for the scale of the assault and panicked in the early stages. Palipehutu-FNL was almost certainly assisted by the other main rebel group, the Conseil national pour la defense de la democratie- Forces pour la defense de la democratie (CNDD-FDD) led by Pierre Nkurunziza, although both groups strongly deny it.

 (Suite)

Need to Transform Military Justice - Lekota.

Defence Minister Mosiua Lekota says radical transformation is needed within the Military's Justice system.

Addressing the media yesterday at a Parliamentary briefing, the minister said there were serious weaknesses in the system.

'Presiding officers are officers in the National Defence Force, such a court presided over by an officer, violates the principal of equality before the law,' minister Lekota said.

'The perceptions are that there is no fair justice system in the military and so the independence of the Judiciary must receive our very close scrutiny,' he added.

Minister Lekota also mentioned a review of penalties that had been inherited from the previous defence force.

The minister said the penalties should be examined to determine whether they conformed to provisions of the Constitution.

'They must be aligned to the human rights culture of our present dispensation,' he said.

He also mentioned that the grievance procedure of the South African National Defence Force (SANDF) was currently being scrutinized.

'A situation in which junior members of the Defence Force might be left with an impression that there is a smothering of some of their complaints must be eliminated,' minister Lekota said.

He said the department was concerned about location of the Ombudsperson within the SANDF.

The minister said there was an argument that the Ombudsperson should reside within the department, a point on which he disagreed. But the matter was receiving attention.

'I think it is wrong because I think the Ombudsperson ought to be independent of the minister, the Commander of the National Defence Force, the Defence Secretary,' Minister Lekota explained.

The minister said the Ombudsman should be free to do its work, without fear of being victimized.

'If the Ombudsperson was to be part and fall under the minister, I would doubt that the arrangement would enable members of the National Defence Force with an efficient and effective institution, but this matter is receiving attention,' minister Lekota said.


SAfrica: Minister calls for urgent review to increase defence spending

The SA National Defence Force's budget allocation needs to be urgently reviewed to prevent South Africa's defence capabilities being completely denuded, Defence Minister Mosiuoa Lekota said on Tuesday [9 September].

Briefing the media at parliament, he said there was now no doubt that the defence budget had to be increased.

The attitude towards defence spending had to be completely reviewed. Decisions should not be taken on an emotional basis, or to avoid criticism, but rather on the basis of reality and what the country needed, he said.

South Africa's current defence spending of only 1.6 per cent of GDP - which even included the strategic arms acquisition programme - was too low to enable the defence force to fulfil its obligations and maintain its capabilities.

Most other countries allocated about two per cent of GDP to defence and considering the South African economy was the strongest in the region, this figure was not unreasonable.

By no stretch of the imagination could that be regarded as excessive, as it left 98 per cent for spending elsewhere, he said.

Following a recent assessment by the defence force's command structures, it was estimated that the SANDF currently needed an additional R2-billion to do everything it was required to do.

Government had been extremely thrifty in its defence spending, but the defence force was steadily losing capabilities, which would be very expensive to replace when the need eventually arose.

Defence capabilities could not be bought "off the shelf", and it would in any event be much cheaper to maintain them instead of losing them altogether.

It was no longer possible for the defence force to continue to "whittle down" its capabilities because of inadequate funding, because then South Africa "will be denuded", Lekota said.

South Africa's obligations and commitments to peacekeeping operations on the African continent had also increased pressure on the already over-stretched budget.

The present size of the budget would not allow the defence force to extend much further afield.

"If there is a need for further peacekeeping involvement, both the budget and the size of the SANDF will have to be reviewed."

This was now under discussion by the department and the defence portfolio committee, Lekota said.


Chaos Over the End-Year Party Funds Leads to the Closure of the School.

The Kei Road Combined school outside Bisho was closed by the Education Department yesterday (subs: Tues) following a second wave of violence by pupils over matric farewell money.

School pupils who wished to remain unnamed, said police and the South African National Defence Force (SANDF) had to rescue the school principal and teachers from from an angry mob of about 500 pupils on Thursday last week.

This came exactly a week after a similar incident at the school where police and the SANDF had to be called in.

The pupils said the mob were "angered" by school principal Loyiso Dyani's refusal to supply R6000 for their farewell party.

SCR deputy president Siviwe Carelsin said the pupils "rampaged" through the school and held Dyani and other teaching staff hostage.

Carelsin said the School Governing Body were holding an urgent meeting on Thursday over the previous weeks rioting when the pupils went on the rampage again.

He said the SGB had "not come up with any solutions".

He said the SRC committee tried to call the rest of the parents to the meeting but "by the time the parents arrived at the school, the principal had decided to call the police and students were angered".

"The gates were locked and the students put a water tank in front of them." He said the school's closure had been ordered by a "King William's Town education district official" who had attended last Thursday's meeting.

A police officer in Kei Road Police Station confirmed the beleaugured school had been closed due to Thursday's riot.

A meeting between the school staff, district officials, parents and the students was due to be held today (subs: Wed).

Education director of communications Professor Danie Breytenbach yesterday (subs: Tues) condemned the "irresponsible behaviour" of the pupils.

"It is totally unacceptable for pupils to act unrespectfully and irresponsibly," said Breytenbach.

"We condemn that in the strongest manner possible." He said the pupils should "learn that in life, sometimes, you cannot get all you want".


Second Sex Row Rocks Army.

The SA National Defence Force has disciplined its second female officer in a month for "riotous" conduct.

Captain "Nellie" Neliswa Mqamelo, deputy commander of a military police unit at the Castle in Cape Town, was punished for a tempestuous "sexual and/or romantic relationship" with a member of the army's lowest rank.

She will be dismissed from the SANDF if her conviction is upheld by a military court of appeal.

Mqamelo's lover, Private Moses Mmasehong Lamola, was fined R600 for his role in the affair but was allowed to remain in the SANDF. He was found guilty of "riotous or unseemly behaviour" and "conduct to the prejudice of military discipline".

The finding came a month after Major Ria Viviers was cashiered for having a sexual relationship with non-commissioned members of a peace-keeping force in the Democratic Republic of Congo.

On Friday last week Mqamelo, reportedly 42, was found guilty on six charges of contravening the military discipline code.

Her two-year affair with Lamola was at the heart of the couple's contempt for military discipline, according to the charge sheet. Their relationship - in itself a breach of the rules - led to charges including assault, being absent without leave (AWOL), dangerous use of a firearm and contempt for senior officers.

A hearing was told that the affair began in October 2000, after Mqamelo met Lamola at the Wynberg military barracks, where she lived in the officers' mess.

During the affair, Lamola slept in Mqamelo's room, negatively affecting his attitude towards senior officers.

The two also used a corporal's bedroom to conduct their affair, as well as a bedroom at 2 Military Hospital, where Lamola "had sexual intercourse and/or spent time relaxing" with the captain.

The affair came to the attention of the couple's commanding officers in January last year when they broke up. Lamola complained to his commanding officer that Mqamelo had pointed a pistol at him. She was found not guilty of this charge.

She was, however, convicted of "common law assault" for attacking a fellow captain. After this incident she stayed away from work for five days.

Called by her commanding officer, Lieutenant-Colonel Raymond Harold Williams, to explain her absence, Mqamelo treated him with "contempt".

The charge sheet accuses her of calling him "a racist and/or shouting at him and/or leaving his office without being properly dismissed and/or paying the requisite military compliments", leading to a conviction for insubordination. She also defied Williams's order to remain on duty.


SA's peacekeeping role. STRETCHED TO THE LIMIT.

SA's peacekeeping role STRETCHED TO THE LIMIT SA peacekeeping troops are policing three of Africa's hotspots. So the news that the over-stretched SA National Defence Force (SANDF) would be required to send only four officers to Liberia as part of a UN contingent must have come as a relief.

When SA first said it would send troops to Liberia, deputy foreign affairs minister Aziz Pahad conceded that the SANDF had already deployed more soldiers abroad than it could afford.

Earlier, defence minister Mosiuoa Lekota said SA would not deploy troops in Liberia because it was stretched to the limit by its peacekeeping role in conflicts in Burundi and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC).

SA also has a small staff of officers at the UN mission in Ethiopia and Eritrea.

But after President Thabo Mbeki's role in persuading Liberian leader Charles Taylor to step down, pressure increased on SA to continue its peace efforts.

SA's commitment to maintain peace and security on the continent comes largely from the white paper on peace missions adopted by parliament in 1999. It is also an extension of SA foreign policy, tied to its obligations to the African Union (AU) and the New Partnership for Africa's Development. But four years down the line, the Institute for Security Studies (ISS) believes it is time to update the document. ISS defence analyst Henri Boschoff says that though SA's role is seen as pivotal to African conflict resolution, "SA has reached its limit and we have to get the message across that this is as much as we can manage".

But that message might be a little more difficult to communicate, especially since Mbeki has long advocated the establishment of an African peacekeeping force, instead of depending on former colonial powers such as Britain, in the case of Sierra Leone, and France in C'te d'Ivoire.

But the costs can be crippling, financially and in terms of manpower. SA has two battalions of 1500 soldiers in Burundi, at the cost of about US$126m/year, Boschoff says. Since the mission is carried out under the auspices of the AU, SA foots the bill.

Returning from a visit to Burundi last Friday, SANDF chief Gen Siphiwe Nyanda said troops will stay on in that country despite funding shortfalls.

It was originally estimated that at least 3000 troops were needed in Burundi, with the remaining numbers made up by Mozambique and Ethiopia. Citing a lack of funds, neither has come through.

The European Union recently granted a170m to the Burundi government, of which only a33m is earmarked for the peacekeeping mission, Boschoff says.

SA has about 1400 soldiers in the DRC, plus 120 technical and support staff. This deployment is under the UN mission, Monuc, which will pay the bill.

The troops in both areas have to be rotated every six months, using what is known as a one-in-three-system. This means that for every battalion deployed, there should be at least two back home - one in training and the other ready to move at short notice.

Add to this at least three battalions deployed on SA's northern border and a further two in reserve, and the extent of the SANDF's commitment is clearer.

It was estimated last year that at least 20% of the troops were not combat fit.

"All this considered, we are doing very well," says Boschoff.

SA soldiers and their commanders are trusted and highly regarded in the DRC and Burundi. Their training and equipment are considered by the UN to be of Nato standard. But SA would have hit its first real crisis had it been asked to send more than just the four senior staff officers to Liberia, says Boschoff. It now appears that the UN force in Liberia may be drawn largely from Namibia, Bangladesh, Pakistan and Ireland, who have offered to send troops. An ISS report says SA's peace missions on the continent have undoubtedly enhanced the country's image internationally, which SA needs to capitalise on. It says the current white paper needs to be revised to make the process more transparent and acceptable to the relevant players. The ISS says the white paper needs refinement, especially in the areas of early warning, regional mandates, clear liaison channels and a domestic mandate and budget.


South Africa: Report alleges discontent, failed integration in defence force

There is a seething discontent in the South African National Defence Force (SANDF). Critics say that integration has failed, communication has broken down, grievance procedures are counterproductive and good leadership is absent. Urgent recommendations and requests to officialdom have languished disregarded for more than two years.

Since 2001, the former black South African Defence Force (SADF) members forum has been clamouring to be heard. There has been no response to communiques sent to the president and the defence minister. The forum represents black soldiers who joined the former SADF before 1994 and served alongside white soldiers. While their white colleagues have apparently been forgiven for their role in oppression, the black foot soldiers of the apartheid regime are still seen as "collaborators".

"We have been prejudiced, rejected and sidelined," said forum spokesman Fikile Mkhwanazi. "We were not given a choice about integration and we were not consulted about the process. We have been trying to get the government to listen to us, but instead they call us hooligans and have us arrested ... [ellipsis as published] The government is busy sending troops to the Congo to sort out their problems but the problem at home has not been sorted out."

Brigadier General Philip Schalkwyk of the Democratic Alliance's standing committee on defence agrees. On such missions, he said, "our shortcomings are being exposed on the world stage".

According to Schalkwyk, transformation in the SANDF has failed in the lower ranks. "There is a theoretical grievance procedure but in practice it does not work. Any soldier who complains to his superior officer is immediately labelled as a troublemaker and is targeted for punitive discipline."

The South African National Defence Union (SANDU) represents white former SADF members, former liberation fighters and troops from the former homelands. SANDU National Secretary Cor van Niekerk said the government shows no willingness to communicate.

"We have been waiting for more than a year to have a meeting with either the Department of Defence or the defence portfolio committee."


SAHRC TO RELEASE REPORT ON HUMAN RIGHTS ON FARMS.

The SA Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) is to release  the findings of a two-year long investigation into human rights conditions on farms.

The SAHRC on Monday said the aim of the inquiry was to determine, in a systematic manner, the nature and causes of human rights violations in farming communities.

It would also report on what could and should be done to deal with such violations in order to ensure that the rights of farm workers were best protected and promoted.

The release of the report comes a month and a half after the commission found the political slogan, "Kill the farmer, kill the Boer," constituted hate speech.

The Freedom Front, who lodged that complaint, argued that the slogan encouraged the killing of farmers.

The SAHRC's report was expected to include evidence gathered countrywide during a series of public hearings.

A hearing in Pretoria in December last year heard from SA National Defence Force officials that security firm employees had in some cases posed as army commandos and abused farm workers.

Even though the incidents were isolated, they created negative public perceptions about the army, Colonel Barry Schoeman, then a senior staff officer at the SANDF's Joint Operations Division, said.

Department of Home Affairs director Eugene Kritzinger told the same hearing that the exploitation of immigrants was rife on farms.

"Abuse in the form of poor working conditions, long working hours and low wages has been reported a lot on farms," he said.

The Congress of SA Trade Unions (Cosatu) told the SAHRC labour inspections on farms were often difficult to carry out as many farmers denied government officials access to their properties under the Property Rights Act.

Many farmers used that law's interpretation of private property and trespass to refuse labour inspectors and trade union officials free access.

In November a labour department official told a hearing in Johannesburg that he did not have enough inspectors to effectively police the implementation of labour legislation on farm.

Kenny Fick, the chief executive officer of the labour department in Gauteng South, told the commission that the department had only 200 inspectors to police not only farms, but also businesses and domestic workers in the province.

"We worked out that if we wanted to visit every place once, it would take us three years to get through every business and farm in our area," he said.

"And then we haven't even responded to complaints and followed up on them."

Fick said a false image of good relations between farmers and their workers were being created. He said the department often found that they were only allowed to speak to one worker on a farm, more often than not a foreman, while other workers "disappeared" if labour inspectors tried to approach them.

He acknowledged, however, that these experiences might create a false image of what was happening on farms because the department only heard about the "bad stories".

"There may be a lot of good stories out there where farm workers are paid well and have decent living conditions that we never hear about due to the nature of our work."

He said a widespread problem was that farmers did not adhere to the Basic Conditions of Employment Act (BCEA).

The department had not yet successfully prosecuted a farmer for contravening the BCEA, often for a lack of evidence.

It was difficult to convince farm workers to testify against farmers because they feared that they would lose not only their jobs, but their whole livelihoods.

In July, a hearing in Limpopo province heard that some farmers there dismissed farm workers when they got pregnant.

An NGO that represents farm dwellers, the Nkuzi Development Association, said farm dwellers' children were subjected to racism and inferior education.

Association spokesman Michael Nefule said the children were expected to walk about 60km a day to and from school.

Nefule said most schools on farms did not offer classes beyond grade seven.